Share Agent Blog
08 Apr 2025
When considering what affects the cost of car insurance, most people think of driving records, credit scores, or even their zip code. But auto tariffs are a surprising factor that’s increasingly influencing what drivers pay.
While they might seem distant from your day-to-day life, the impact of auto tariffs on insurance premiums is very real. These international trade policies shape how much it costs to repair or replace vehicles, which eventually trickle down into your monthly auto insurance bill.
In this post, we’ll break down how auto tariffs work, why they matter for your vehicle insurance, and how to protect your wallet from rising car insurance rates.
What Are Auto Tariffs and How Do They Work?
Auto tariffs are taxes a government imposes on imported cars or auto parts. These taxes increase the product's price coming into the country, affecting how much consumers and businesses pay on the ground.
Why Are They Imposed?
Governments implement tariffs to:
Protect domestic industries
Influence trade behavior
Generate national revenue
In the auto sector, tariffs are often used to encourage consumers to buy locally produced cars by making imported options more expensive.
Brief History and Updates
Tariffs on foreign vehicles aren’t new. For example, the U.S. has maintained a 25% tariff on imported trucks since the 1960s. More recently, global trade disputes have led to discussions about broader tariffs, including:
Steel (25%) and aluminum (10%) tariffs introduced in 2018
Proposed but unfinalized tariffs of up to 25% on all foreign vehicles
Even without sweeping new rules, more minor tariffs on individual parts have added up over time—particularly as automakers source components worldwide.
The Direct Impact of Auto Tariffs on Insurance Rates
So, how exactly do tariffs affect auto insurance premiums? The short answer: they drive up costs at nearly every level of the repair and claims process. Since insurance companies calculate premiums based mainly on what they might have to pay in the event of a claim, anything that makes cars more expensive to fix or replace directly impacts your car insurance rates. Let’s break it down into two core ways auto tariffs play a role:
Higher Repair and Replacement Costs
A huge portion of modern vehicles—regardless of whether they’re manufactured domestically or abroad—relies on a global supply chain. This means that even U.S.-assembled cars often include parts imported from other countries. When tariffs are imposed on those imported parts, it leads to a ripple effect on repair costs.
For example:
Brake systems, transmissions, airbag modules, and electronic sensors are often sourced from international suppliers.
Body panels and windshields might be shipped from factories overseas.
Even minor elements like interior trim or wiring harnesses can come from tariff-affected regions.
When these components become more expensive to import, the overall cost of repairing a damaged vehicle increases significantly. For insurers, this means higher payouts on collision and comprehensive claims. Whether it’s a minor fender-bender or a more serious accident, the bill for bringing your car back to pre-accident condition is higher than it used to be.
Additionally, cars that require specialized or rare parts—standard in luxury or foreign vehicles—are hit hardest. Not only do these parts cost more under tariffs, but they also often involve longer wait times, custom orders, or even overseas shipping logistics. All of this drives up labor and repair shop fees, too.
When insurers face higher claim expenses across the board, they pass those costs along to customers by raising auto insurance premiums—even for those who haven’t filed a recent claim.
Higher Vehicle Values = Higher Claim Payouts
Auto tariffs don’t just affect parts—they also influence the overall price of new vehicles. Automakers often adjust pricing to compensate when imported cars become more expensive due to tariffs. This impacts new car buyers directly, but it also affects everyone’s insurance indirectly.
Here’s why: when a vehicle is declared a total loss—meaning the cost to repair it exceeds its value—insurers pay out its current market value. So if tariffs have driven up vehicle prices across the board, the amount insurers have to pay in total loss claims increases.
For example:
A vehicle that might have been valued at $28,000 before a tariff could now cost $30,000 or more.
If that vehicle is totaled in an accident, the insurance company is responsible for the higher payout.
Multiply that across thousands of claims, and you get a significant rise in the insurer’s annual expenses.
What does this mean for drivers? Even if your car isn't brand new, overall market value trends can influence what insurers expect to pay in the event of a loss. If vehicles are simply more expensive to buy and replace, insurance companies will proactively increase premiums to cover future risks.
It’s also important to note that rising vehicle costs affect leased vehicles and financing structures, which may require higher coverage limits, pushing premiums upward.
Which Vehicles Are Most Affected by Auto Tariffs?
Not every vehicle is equally impacted. The effect of tariffs on car insurance rates depends on several factors:
Domestic vs. Foreign-Made Vehicles
Cars built entirely in the U.S. generally avoid the bulk of tariff-related costs. However, few modern vehicles are 100% domestic. Many models—even from U.S.-based companies—include imported parts.
Foreign-manufactured vehicles, especially those assembled overseas, are more likely to:
Be hit with higher import tariffs.
Depend on international supply chains for parts.
Luxury vs. Economy Cars
Luxury vehicles often:
Use more advanced technology.
Require pricier, internationally sourced components.
Have higher repair costs overall.
As a result, they’re more likely to be impacted by tariffs, and their car insurance premiums often reflect this. Economy models with simpler parts and easier access to replacements fare better.
How Auto Tariffs Influence Claims and Coverage Options
In addition to affecting repair costs, tariffs can also reshape the types of insurance coverage drivers choose—or even what insurers are willing to offer.
Rising Costs for Collision and Comprehensive Coverage
These two types of coverage—collision and comprehensive—are most sensitive to repair costs. As tariffs make fixes more expensive:
Premiums for these coverages go up.
Some insurers may adjust or limit specific options.
Deductibles and Policy Structure
Drivers may see higher suggested deductibles or reduced coverage flexibility to offset increased costs. For example:
A $500 deductible might become $1,000
Optional coverages (like OEM part replacements) may become pricier.
Being proactive about your policy structure is key in a shifting cost environment.
What Can Drivers Do to Minimize the Impact of Rising Insurance Costs?
Even if you can’t control tariffs, there are ways to protect yourself from their ripple effects on your auto insurance.
Compare Quotes from Multiple Providers
Insurance companies vary widely in how they assess risk and price policies. Some may have already adjusted their rates due to tariffs, while others haven't. That’s why it’s wise to:
Reevaluate your policy annually.
Use comparison tools or local insurance agents who can get quotes from several companies.
This approach helps ensure you’re not overpaying just because of one insurer’s model.
Use comparison tools or local insurance agents who can get quotes from several companies. For example, MarketWatch suggests that shopping around for insurance can help mitigate the impact of rising premiums due to tariffs.
Look for Discounts
Ask your insurer about:
Safe driver discounts
Multi-policy bundling (like auto + home)
Anti-theft and safety feature savings
Even if base premiums rise, these offers can reduce out-of-pocket costs.
Choose Tariff-Resistant Vehicles
When shopping for a new car, consider:
Domestic models with mostly U.S.-sourced parts
Vehicles with good safety ratings (often rewarded with lower premiums)
Makes and models with widely available replacement parts
Before buying, a quick chat with an insurance agent can help you assess long-term ownership and insurance costs.
Auto tariffs might seem like an issue reserved for trade negotiators and automakers, but their effects are where you feel them most—your monthly expenses. The impact of auto tariffs on insurance premiums is a genuine concern for everyday drivers, especially as global supply chains continue to shift.
While you can’t avoid every increase, you can take control of your coverage. Staying informed, choosing your vehicle wisely, and comparing car insurance rates from different sources can go a long way toward keeping your policy affordable.
Working with a knowledgeable local insurance agent can make all the difference. They’ll understand how these broader trends affect you specifically and help you adjust your coverage accordingly.
Ready to take control of your car insurance costs? Don’t let auto tariffs drive your premiums higher than necessary. Connect with trusted, local insurance experts at IANearMe to compare rates and find a personalized policy that fits your budget and lifestyle.
FAQs
Why do auto tariffs increase car insurance premiums?
Tariffs make imported vehicles and parts more expensive. Insurance companies pass those higher costs onto consumers through raised premiums, especially for coverage that involves repairs and replacements.
Which types of cars are most affected by auto tariffs?
Foreign-made and luxury vehicles are typically the most affected. These models often rely heavily on imported components and cost more to repair or replace.
How can I find affordable car insurance despite rising costs?
Shop around, compare quotes from multiple providers, and ask about discounts. Working with a local agent who knows the industry landscape can help you tailor a policy that balances coverage and cost.